Travolution

Kayak claims Tripadvisor has 'polluted the web'

Travel metasearch specialist Kayak will go head-to-head with Tripadvisor when it unveils its revamped reviews site at the end of March.

Kayak chief executive Steve Hafner said the company was planning a significant marketing push for Travelpost in the coming weeks.

Travelpost, he claimed, would do a better job on independent reviews than Tripadvisor.

“I don’t think the consumer sees Tripadvisor as comprehensive or unbiased. It is hard to get to the review and they don’t display the website address or contact details for the hotel.”

He added that Tripadvisor had become very “commercially driven.”

“It got an early lead and hotel reviews become synonymous with their brand name but over time they have polluted the web with over-commercialisation. I think we will do it much better.”

Hafner was speaking to Travolution in response to Tripadvisor’s launch of a flight metasearch tool, unveiled last week.

He said Kayak had been expecting the move for some time and predicted it would be kept  small so as not to cannibalise Expedia’s business.

“It will cannibalise it a bit but they will be careful about how much. I don’t think anyone is going to let Expedia be cannibalised, they will be very careful about how they manage it. I don’t think they are intending to spend marketing dollars pushing it.”

Hafner added that overall Tripadvisor’s flight booking tool would help grow the metasearch space.

“As more consumers become aware of the deficiencies of just searching Expedia or Orbitz they will embrace metasearch. Most people are not aware that Kayak or Tripadvisor even exist so as they become aware they will use them more often and prefer them.

He also said a hotels metasearch tool was unlikely.

“It would have been more interesting but they make a lot more money on hotels with the current model then they would on metasearch.”

A Tripadvisor spokesman said: "Tripadvisor's unique users keep growing, as does its content, which indicates strongly that consumers still see TripAdvisor as an independent source for making decisions about their travel."

Readers' Comments

  Chris @ Nozio says...

Wake up & smell the coffee! Users are waking up to the idea of having direct contact with hotel suppliers

Posted: 27 March 2009 |   Report Abuse

  Trip says...

First, I think it is interesting that Mr. Hafner makes a disparaging comment regarding Orbitz, when Kayak offers Orbitz and its sister site CheapTickets.com as booking options. Next, with tens of millions of reviews on it, TripAdvisor is clearly a known resource. As with any type of review site, it's important to view a hotel's or destination's comments in aggregate. Third, the argument could be made that Hotels.com and Hotwire compete with Expedia.com to some degree. So I do not agree with Mr. Hafner's belief that TA will not launch hotel meta - if the bean counters at TA and Expedia Inc. think they can increase revenues from such an offering, I expect they'll bring that to market. Mr. Hafner would serve himself, and his colleagues at Kayak, much better if he focused on his product advantages rather than insulting his competition. Kayak has any useful tools, a terrific UI and is a leading user of rich Internet applications. So let's hear how Kayak will make the process and user experience of hotel reviews better for the consumer, and for hotels/destinations, and leave the "going negative" activities to the politicians.

Posted: 10 March 2009 |   Report Abuse

  Todd says...

I think some of you guys are missing it. The UI on TA stinks and makes for a poor user experience. Some of you say company's are out to make money and will bias to do so. Well that might be the way TA makes its money but if Kayak were to bias anything it would go against what they are about. Giving the user unbiased results and the freedom to filter the results as they choose. I rank TA up there with Yelp and look forward to Kayak's review site TravelPost.com

Posted: 10 March 2009 |   Report Abuse

  Dan says...

Um, Steve, I think you may be a bit off in your observations. TripAdvisor has had hotel metasearch in one form or another for many years, and their current iteration dominates the site's homepage (so much for "won't promote it heavily"). They search brand sites, Expedia/Hotels.com, and other online agency sites that are not part of the EXPE company. Steve reminds me of the story about the gnat and the elephant...

Posted: 10 March 2009 |   Report Abuse

  Brandon says...

This is a non-issue. You mean that TripAdvisor has found they can make more money by being biased - and they are taking advantage of it? WOW!!! ...tell me that every business in the same position wouldn't do the same, especially in these economic times. Kayak's attempt to damage TripAdvisor with this statement is ludicrous. They would do the same thing if they could. Likewise, if consumers think online reviews posted ANYWHERE on the web are unbiased and free of manipulation then they are living in a fantasy world.

Posted: 10 March 2009 |   Report Abuse

Your Comments

Your Name: Your Comment:
Enter the digits in the picture above: