Travolution

Exclusive: 'Fake review' firms are not an issue, says TripAdvisor

Hoteliers are being plagued by companies promising to post positive reviews on high profile sites such as TripAdvisor in return for a monthly fee.

The companies claim to be able to post the reviews from different places across the globe so as to avoid being picked up by protection put in place by review sites.

Ray Rock of the Llandudno-based Headlands Hotel said the practise risked bringing the credibility of reviews sites under question.

"Lots of people are doing it, I know one hotel that has got 500 reviews, but I have not bothered with it because it’s dishonest and I would rather stand on a just reputation," he said.

He added that another hotel had received a number of reviews before opening to the public.

TripAdvisor vice president of marketing for Europe Alison Copus said the integrity of its reviews was protected through a screening process prior to posting, in-house technology to help rifle out attempts to get around the system, and the community reporting suspicious activity.

"There are companies that claim they can submit reviews and boost a property’s standing in the TripAdvisor popularity index," she said. 

"We have several of these companies on our radar already, and the properties have been penalised appropriately. Using these services is against our rules and will result in penalties.

"In addition to being a violation of our terms of service and an unethical practice, it is also illegal to post fake reviews in the United Kingdom (among other countries) pursuant to the EU Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, adopted by these countries."

She claimed that attempts to post fraudulent information on TripAdvisor were rare because hoteliers understand they are risking their reputation.

Can review sites like Tripadvisor really wheedle out fake reviews? Are review sites losing their credibility? Post your comments below.

Readers' Comments

  Guillaume says...

Sites like Travelrepublic have a long way to go to cover as many hotels as TripAdvisor. Also TravelRepublic has 165,000 reviews (post stay) vs. TripAdvisor with 30 million reviews. Where do you think the majority of us will go to? Of course, you can't never be sure about the hotel you are going to stay in. But it is the same a lot of choices in your life. For instance, which next mobile phone should I be upgraded to or which Blue Ray Player should I buy...

Posted: 26 January 2010 |   Report Abuse

  Steve Dean says...

The ongoing concerns about anonymous reviews can only be good news for those sites which only collect reviews following a booking, for example www.travelrepublic.co.uk and www.booking.com. Travelrepublic posted a blog the other day claiming over 165,000 reviews. http://blog.travelrepublic.co.uk/hotels-with-the-x-factor-your-favourite-hotels-in-2009 I struggle with reviews because you get negative feedback about a lot of hotels, except the top few, and end up not wanting to go anywhere! I would much prefer to read a review from someone who has definitely been to the hotel though, so have wondered about Trip Advisor and indeed some of these review type forums, where you cant always be sure. Steve

Posted: 22 January 2010 |   Report Abuse

  katerina margari Diana Group Hotels says...

It is better for hoteliers to become i little bit more honest with themselves and begin to have a clear strategy with all social media sites like Trip Advisor. People will appreciate if a business responds to negative reviews in a proper way. It is a fact that a strategy like this can bring people in. You can not satisfy everyone. We are all human and people can understand this.

Posted: 22 January 2010 |   Report Abuse

Your Comments

Your Name: Your Comment:
Enter the digits in the picture above: